Introduction
Nepal is a country striving to improve its healthcare system. It is grappling with a significant issue: the mass migration of its medical professionals. Between 2020 and 2023, the Nepal Medical Council (NMC) reported that 8,624 doctors registered. An astounding 6,368 obtained Good Standing Certificates (GSCs) to work or study abroad. This alarming trend raises questions about the sustainability of Nepal’s healthcare system and the reasons driving this brain drain.
The Data Speaks: A Rising Exodus
Annual Registrations vs. Migration
The NMC’s data reveals a worrying pattern:
2020: 2,000 doctors registered; 769 sought GSCs.
2021: 1,716 registered; 1,327 sought GSCs.
2022: 2,085 registered; 1,954 sought GSCs.
2023: 2,692 registered; 2,318 sought GSCs.
This means that nearly 74% of newly registered doctors are preparing to leave Nepal.
Factors Contributing to Doctor Migration
Several factors contribute to the migration of Nepalese doctors:
- Inadequate Compensation: The salary structure for medical professionals in Nepal is often not commensurate with their qualifications and workload.
- Limited Career Advancement: Opportunities for specialization and professional growth within Nepal are limited, prompting doctors to seek better prospects abroad.
- Workplace Challenges: Issues such as inadequate facilities, lack of modern equipment, and administrative hurdles contribute to job dissatisfaction.
- Safety Concerns: Instances of violence against healthcare workers have been reported, leading to concerns about personal safety.
- Policy Gaps: The absence of robust policies to retain medical professionals exacerbates the migration trend.
Preferred Destinations
Countries attracting Nepalese doctors include:
United States: 843 GSCs in 2023.
United Kingdom: 505 GSCs.
Maldives: 395 GSCs.
Australia: 166 GSCs.
India: 186 GSCs.
Advanced infrastructure, better salaries, and career growth opportunities make these destinations appealing.
Why Are Doctors Leaving?
- Low Compensation
Nepalese doctors are significantly underpaid compared to international standards:
Intern Doctors: NPR 10,000–13,500 monthly.
Residential Doctors: NPR 18,000–24,000 in private hospitals.
Government Doctors: NPR 48,737 for entry-level medical officers.
These figures pale in comparison to what doctors earn abroad. For instance, a doctor in the U.S. or UK earns 20 to 100 times more.
- Lack of Career Development
Opportunities for specialization, research, and continuing medical education in Nepal are scarce. The absence of advanced training facilities pushes doctors to seek better prospects overseas. - Inadequate Infrastructure
Healthcare facilities in Nepal often lack modern equipment. They also lack the necessary technology. This deficiency makes it difficult for doctors to practice advanced medicine effectively. - Unsafe Work Environment
Frequent cases of violence against healthcare workers create an unappealing work environment. Hospitals lack adequate safety measures. - Overburdened Schedules
Doctors in Nepal work excessively long shifts. These shifts often exceed 40 hours. This violates both the Labor Act (2074) and international norms. Prolonged working hours lead to burnout, emotional exhaustion, and even medical errors. - Policy Gaps
The government lacks coherent policies to retain doctors. There is no framework for competitive salaries, structured career pathways, or incentives for rural service.
Impact of Migration on Nepal’s Healthcare
- Healthcare Access
The migration of skilled doctors exacerbates the shortage of healthcare professionals, particularly in rural areas. Nearly 78% of Nepal’s population resides in rural regions, where the doctor-patient ratio is alarmingly low. - Public Health Crisis
Fewer doctors mean compromised healthcare delivery. This could lead to increased mortality rates. It also results in the inability to manage public health emergencies effectively. - Economic Loss
The government’s investment in medical education, particularly for scholarship-based students, is wasted when these graduates migrate. The country loses both its financial investment and the potential economic contributions of these professionals.
Proposed Solutions: Building a Resilient System
- Enhance Salaries and Benefits
The Barakoti Committee Report recommends revising salary scales:
MBBS/BDS Doctors: NPR 100,000–125,000.
MD/MS Specialists: NPR 150,000–175,000.
DM/MCh Specialists: NPR 225,000–250,000.
- Improve Working Conditions
Limit shifts to 24 hours with mandatory rest periods.
Enforce strict anti-violence measures in healthcare settings.
Ensure comprehensive health insurance for doctors and their families.
- Incentivize Rural Service
Provide bonuses and allowances for doctors serving in rural and underserved areas.
Offer career advancement credits for rural postings.
- Develop Infrastructure
Invest in upgrading healthcare facilities. Ensure access to modern equipment. Provide specialized care units in both urban and rural areas. - Mandate Service from Scholarship Graduates
Introduce binding agreements. Require scholarship recipients to serve in Nepal for a specified term. They must do this before pursuing opportunities abroad. - Strengthen Career Pathways
Partner with international institutions for training and research collaborations.
Develop structured programs for continuing medical education (CME) and specialization.
Explore the Suggestion Report by MoHP’s Committee
Global Lessons: Retention Strategies from Other Countries
India:
Scholarships tied to mandatory rural service.
Subsidized education with career advancement incentives.
Bangladesh:
Attractive allowances for rural service.
International collaboration for specialized training.
Philippines:
Government-backed loan forgiveness programs for doctors serving domestically.
Nepal can adapt these strategies to its unique context to address its brain drain.
Recommendations to Mitigate Doctor Migration
To address this issue, the following measures are recommended:
- Enhance Compensation: Revising the salary structure to offer competitive remuneration can help retain medical professionals.
- Expand Career Opportunities: Developing infrastructure for advanced medical training and research within Nepal can provide doctors with growth opportunities domestically.
- Improve Working Conditions: Investing in healthcare facilities and ensuring a safe working environment can reduce job dissatisfaction.
- Implement Retention Policies: Formulating policies that incentivize doctors to work in Nepal, such as loan forgiveness programs or bonuses for rural service, can be effective.
- Strengthen Healthcare Infrastructure: Upgrading medical facilities and ensuring the availability of necessary equipment can improve job satisfaction among healthcare workers.
Call to Action: A Collective Effort
Nepal’s doctor migration crisis is not just about personal choices. It is actually a symptom of systemic issues within the healthcare sector. Addressing these challenges requires collaboration among stakeholders:
Government: Implement policies to enhance salaries, improve infrastructure, and provide safety measures.
Medical Institutions: Develop partnerships for international training and ensure modern facilities.
Civil Society: Advocate for healthcare reforms and hold authorities accountable.
Conclusion: Retaining Talent for a Healthier Nepal
The exodus of Nepalese doctors is both a challenge and an opportunity. With the right interventions, such as better compensation, improved working conditions, and robust policies, Nepal can retain its medical talent. This approach ensures a sustainable healthcare system for future generations. This issue demands urgent and sustained action to build a resilient, equitable, and accessible healthcare system that benefits all.
Discover more from Public Health Concern Nepal
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
